Dan Price (thwack) wrote,
Dan Price
thwack

So many people on here tend to post song lyrics... I really wish I could see the point of that. I'm not saying I don't understand the purpose - I understand they post them because the lyrics represent how they're feeling at the time. But I, as a reader, can't recreate that feeling just by reading the lyrics alone. I need to hear the chords and rhythms behind the lyrics in order to undrestand their true meaning the way the composer intended.

In most cases, I assume the person who posts the lyrics knows how the song sounds, and the feeling they're trying to convey really is the feeling created by the full song, not just the lyrics. But since I'm usually not familiar with the songs from which lyrics are chosen, I have nothing but the words to go by. That's like someone who paints a beautiful picture telling you to paint the exact same thing, but they don't show you the picture. They just give you the colors of paint you'll need. Sure, colors can convey SOME meaning, but not merely as much as the spatial patterns and arrangements the artist creates with them.

Another thing that bugs me about this practice of lyric-posting is that it almost seems like a form of cheating... as if to say "I'm not artistic enough to write my own poems, but here's something someone else wrote that's close enough." Of course there's nothing wrong with not being artistic - I'm not very artistic myself - but when I read people's journals on here, I'm reading them to hear what THEY have to say. If everything is just quotes of other people's words, it seems kind of pointless to me.
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 8 comments